PTI suspect’s bail cancelled in Rangers personnel hit-and-run case

Sabir Shah Hoti • November 17, 2026 • Pakistan

The Islamabad High Court (IHC) has set aside the bail order granted to Muhammad Hashim Abbasi, an accused in the case involving the deaths of three Rangers personnel who were run over by a vehicle during the Pakistan Tehreek-e-Insaf (PTI) protest in Islamabad on November 26, 2024.

Chief Justice Sardar Muhammad Sarfraz Dogar, in a written judgment, annulled the trial court’s March 1, 2025, bail order and referred the matter back to the Anti-Terrorism Court (ATC) for a fresh decision in accordance with the law.

The High Court also directed all parties to appear before the trial court on November 25, 2026.

IHC orders fresh examination of bail application

According to the written judgment, legal objections had been raised against the bail granted to Muhammad Hashim Abbasi by the Anti-Terrorism Court.

After examining the arguments presented by both sides, the Islamabad High Court declared the earlier bail order legally unsustainable and directed the trial court to reconsider the application.

The court clarified that the legal principles governing the granting of bail differ from those applicable to the cancellation of bail already granted.

It observed that once bail has been approved, its cancellation requires exceptionally strong and compelling circumstances.

However, the court maintained that a bail order can be set aside if it was issued on unlawful grounds or through an incorrect interpretation of the law.

Investigation identified accused as driver, court observes

Referring to the investigation record, the Islamabad High Court noted that investigators had identified Muhammad Hashim Abbasi as the person allegedly driving the vehicle involved in the incident.

The Prosecutor General argued that the Anti-Terrorism Court’s decision to grant bail was inconsistent with the law and the evidence available on record.

According to the prosecution, the trial court had failed to provide sufficient legal justification for treating the case as one requiring further inquiry.

The Prosecutor General further maintained that all necessary investigative procedures, including the identification parade, had been completed in accordance with legal requirements.

The prosecution argued that the available evidence connected the accused to the alleged offence and that his absence from the initial First Information Report (FIR) could not, by itself, justify granting bail.

Defence challenges identification parade

Meanwhile, counsel for Muhammad Hashim Abbasi informed the court that the accused was currently imprisoned in connection with another case, explaining his absence from the proceedings.

The defence argued that more than one and a half years had passed since bail was granted and that the accused had not violated any bail conditions during that period.

According to his lawyer, Abbasi had regularly appeared before the trial court and had not misused the concession of bail.

The defence also challenged the legality of the identification parade, arguing that it had not been conducted in accordance with the prescribed legal procedures.

The lawyer maintained that the identification parade could not be treated as reliable evidence against the accused because of the alleged procedural irregularities.

Strong grounds required for bail cancellation: IHC

In its judgment, the Islamabad High Court explained the distinction between granting bail and cancelling bail already approved by a competent court.

The court observed that the cancellation of bail requires extraordinary and compelling reasons, particularly when an accused has already been granted liberty through a judicial order.

It emphasised that allegations or general objections alone cannot justify depriving an individual of personal freedom.

Referring to constitutional protections, the high court observed that the right to liberty is a fundamental right that cannot be taken away merely on the basis of vague allegations.

However, the court clarified that an earlier bail order may be set aside if it was passed on unlawful grounds or reflected an incorrect application of legal principles.

Absence of name from FIR not sufficient for bail

The Islamabad High Court also addressed an important legal question concerning the significance of an accused person’s name being absent from the FIR.

The court ruled that the absence of an accused’s name from the FIR does not automatically constitute sufficient grounds for granting bail.

It further observed that such an omission cannot independently establish that a case falls within the category of further inquiry.

According to the judgment, courts must examine the complete investigation record, identification proceedings, available evidence and overall circumstances before deciding a bail application.

The court stressed that the decision must be based on a comprehensive assessment of the relevant legal and factual material rather than relying solely on whether the accused was initially named in the FIR.

Background: Three Rangers personnel killed during PTI protest

The case relates to the November 26, 2024, PTI protest in Islamabad, during which three Rangers personnel lost their lives after being run over by a vehicle.

Following the incident, a criminal case was registered at Ramna Police Station, and Muhammad Hashim Abbasi was arrested on allegations that he had been driving the vehicle involved.

On March 1, 2025, the Islamabad Anti-Terrorism Court granted the accused post-arrest bail against surety bonds worth Rs50,000.

The trial court had observed that, at first glance, the case warranted further inquiry into the allegations against the accused.

Subsequently, the Prosecutor General approached the Islamabad High Court, challenging the legality of the bail order and seeking its cancellation.

After hearing arguments from both sides and examining the relevant legal principles, the high court set aside the earlier order and referred the matter back to the trial court.

Legal implications of the judgment

The Islamabad High Court’s decision highlights the importance of examining investigative evidence and following established legal procedures when deciding bail applications.

The judgment makes clear that the absence of an accused’s name from an FIR cannot be treated as the sole determining factor in granting bail.

The trial court will now be required to reconsider the evidence, including the identification parade, the allegation that Abbasi was driving the vehicle and other findings recorded during the investigation.

All parties have been directed to appear before the trial court on November 25, 2026, when the bail matter will be taken up for reconsideration.

The high court’s ruling sets aside the previous bail order but does not constitute a determination of the accused’s guilt. The criminal allegations remain subject to judicial proceedings.